WASHINGTON (DTN) -- Domestic sheep producers are one step closer to receiving trade protections against lamb imports from Australia and New Zealand that they say have caused serious injury to the U.S. industry.
The U.S. International Trade Commission (USITC) voted 3-3 on the investigation, resulting in a split decision on whether imported lamb has caused serious injury to domestic producers.
As a result of the tie vote, the USITC will hold a public hearing on potential remedies Dec. 1 and submit a report of its determinations and remedy recommendations to President Donald Trump by Jan. 11, 2027. The president will then make the final decision.
"While we would have preferred a clear affirmative decision, a tie still results in an important step forward for American sheep producers and reflects the collective efforts of our industry to bring this issue before federal decisionmakers," said Ben Lehfeldt, American Sheep Industry Association (ASI) board president.
Since October 2025, the American Sheep Industry Association has sought an investigation by the Office of the U.S. Trade Representative into the impact of lamb imports on domestic producers under Section 201 of the Trade Act of 1974.
The U.S. sheep and lamb inventory totaled 4.99 million head at the beginning of 2026. Meanwhile, nearly 79% of the 258 million pounds of lamb consumed in the United States in 2025 was supplied by Australian imports.
Since the USITC's last Section 201 investigation into lamb meat in 1999, imports have increased from just over 30% of the U.S. market to more than 70% today, according to ASI.
The association argues that increased imports have resulted in lost sales, revenue and market share for domestic producers as imported lamb, particularly from Australia and New Zealand, has been sold at lower prices than American lamb.
U.S. sheep numbers peaked at 51 million head in 1884. By 2016, inventories had fallen to nearly 5 million head, with numbers remaining relatively unchanged over the past decade, according to USDA National Agricultural Statistics Service (NASS) data.
Imported lamb supplements domestic production during the U.S. off-season, helping maintain a year-round supply for grocery stores and restaurants.
DROUGHT AND IMPORTS
An analysis commissioned by ASI and conducted by Georgetown Economic Services LLC found that imported lamb was sold at prices averaging 10.8% below domestic product, with some price gaps approaching 19.5%, putting pressure on domestic producers' profitability.
Tied with inventory decline, it paints a harsh outlook for U.S. sheep production.
Across several Western states, inventories have declined year over year, including California (1%), Idaho (6.4%), Oregon (1.4%), Utah (1.8%), Montana (1.6%) and Wyoming (5.1%), according to 2026 NASS data. However, inventories in several other states have also increased, including Colorado (1.2%), Kansas (2.5%), South Dakota (2.4%) and Texas (4.5%).
Despite the push for trade remedies, drought and other production challenges also have played a significant role in the decline of the U.S. sheep industry.
Around 73% of the movement in U.S. wholesale lamb prices was attributable to drought, compared with 2% attributed to imports, the commissioned report said.
AUSTRALIA DISPUTES IMPORT CLAIMS
Australian industry representatives have pushed back against claims that imports are responsible for the struggles facing U.S. sheep producers.
"The success of the U.S. lamb category has been built on the contribution of both domestic and imported product, and by working collaboratively we can continue to grow the lamb category in the U.S.," said Tim Ryan, chief executive officer of the Australian Meat Industry Council.
Australian industry representatives argue that imports provide products that complement domestic production and that exporters have built a mutually beneficial relationship with the U.S. market.
Their imports also haven't surged. Lamb imports increased 14.7% from 2021 to 2025, compared with an average annual increase of 4.4% from 2010 to 2020, they told the USITC.
Representatives from both countries brought competing delegations to an in-person hearing Oct. 16 to present evidence in the investigation.
"It's important to be clear, this outcome alone does not impose any new trade restrictions. While the remedy phase of the investigation progresses, Australian lamb continues to enter the U.S. on the same terms as before," said Bonnie Skinner, chief executive officer of Sheep Producers Australia, emphasizing that the process was not yet concluded.
Read more:
-- ASI Press Release on Split Vote: https://myemail.constantcontact.com/…
-- Australian campaign to fight tariff remedy: https://protectlambsupply.org/…
-- USDA sheep and goat data: https://esmis.nal.usda.gov/…
Jake Zajkowski can be reached at jake.zajkowski@dtn.com
Follow him on social platform X @jzajkow
(c) Copyright 2026 DTN, LLC. All rights reserved.